Thank you all for the replies thus far. I see the thread was moved - my apologies!

- I had initially put the question under "general marketing" because my intent was to ask in the general sense, not just in regards to my website. I only mentioned the website because that's where I was at when the question arose. But I can see where this question fits under either category.
EDIT:
OH! And I just saw the other threads asking the same question. Before posting, I had done a search on the word "we" and got zero results. I don't know what I did wrong!

I'm always careful not to post without searching first (which would explain my low post count)