I went with
Myron and got exactly what I wanted for a great price. The trick is to get your name on their mailing list and order when they send you a discount code or coupon. I ended up with 150 pens for just under $50 shipped by waiting.
Bonus (or annoyance depending on how you feel about it) about once every month or two I get an envelope in the mail from them with a "sample" product. Usually other types of normal pens but I've gotten a calendar, pocket date book, keychain, pen shell with screwdriver and bits inside, pen/mini flashlight combo, etc. all with my company name on them.
Just found coupon code Welcome10 - it gives you 10% off your order
~C