Hey Vanessa, once you get good at customizing themes, the new WordPress default Twenty Ten theme is a solid base and really easy to customize. Just saying that one doesn't always have to pay for a theme to come out with a very nice site in the end.
I did use Elegant Theme's Coldstone/Nature theme for my site, but by the time I got done with it, it looked nothing like the theme except the green menu (and that I made wider, LOL). Now I've been dreaming up a new site redesign for SunRise - just not enough hours in the day to implement it.